Atlantic Popular Latest SectionsMagazine More Subscribe IDEAS Don't Strip ISIS Fighters of Citizenship Shamima Begum and Hoda Muthana are products of their own societies-they can't just be disowned EB 25 201 Graeme Wood wri t The Atlan MORE BY GRAEME WOOD Will John Bolton Bring on rmageddon-Or Stave It Off? GRAEME WOOD The Two Amy Klobuchars GRAEME WOOD The Vatican and the Gulf Have a Common Enemy GRAEME WOOD Jamal Khashoggi?s rder Remains a Renu Begum the sister of Shamima Begum holds a photo of her sister REUTERS ery GRAEME WOOD In October 1959 Lee Harvey Oswald presented himself to the US consul in Moscow and attempted without success to rid himself of his US citizenship The Warren Commission Report describes his frustration First he told the consul Richard E Snyder that he wanted to give up his citizenship The consul refused to accept his declaration so Oswald picked up a pen and put it in writing To remove doubt he added that he intended to defect to the Soviet Union and pass along secrets he had learned during his service as a US marine Denied again he wrote to the consul days later protesting the deprivation of his legal right to stop being American To him being American was a disease and his government was withholding the cure har Tweet Email Two women Shamima Begum of the United Kingdom and Hoda Muthana of the US recently discovered that the cure is worse than the disease Both had traveled to join the Islamic State Begum at 15 and Muthana at 2o and upon arrival urged others to follow them or to kill random people at home A common ritual among travelers to Islamic State territory is a bonfire of passports symbolizing the shedding of their former nationality Muthana appears to have burned hers and both women left little doubt that they intended like Oswald to leave their countries and betray them to an enemy state Kurdish forces are now holding them captive and they both want to go home On Tuesday the UK informed Begum that it had revoked her citizenship The next day Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said that Muthana too is someone else's problem He declared that she was never a citizen to begin with because she was born in the United States while her father was here as a Yemeni diplomat and children born to diplomats cannot claim birthright American citizenship Muthana's family claims that the father had left diplomatic service when she was born and that they gave the Obama administration proof of that when first confronted with this argument in 2016 The upshot for both women now marooned in the Syrian desert is that they are alone and have very grim futures How easy should it be to give up your citizenship? In the era of Oswald it could be difficult-like joining aspirants until they kneel in the snow for a few days outside the monastery or consulate's doors Now a US citizen can stop being American with a single visit to a consulate Most renounce not for ideological reasons but to avoid the complications of living as an American expatriate subject to dual taxation and bureaucratic requirements far more onerous than for expatriates of almost any other country an especially se lective monastic order that turns away But to argue that these women have given up their citizenship through informal means-by tweeting ghoulishly burning a passport or joining a terrorist group is still a novelty and according to an emerging consensus a bad idea Most terrorism experts seem to agree that stripping the citizenship of ISIS fighters is either imprudent or illegal or both A worthless traitor in the media blames America for other worthless traitors in ISIS and tells us to let them in Meme

Being alone

America

Arguing

Bad

Children

family

ISIS

Obama

Lee Harvey Oswald

American

Common

Email

Home

Passport

Reuters

Snow

United

Women

Kurdish

Soviet

United Kingdom

Vatican

Doubt

Government

Living

Never

Soviet Union

Success

Terrorism

Single

According

how

kingdom

media

united states

idea

the cure

her

proof

random

next

wanted

moscow

secretary of state

grim

amy

ideas

citizen

him

travelers

can

doors

refused

birthright

union

easy

group

desert

era

photo

secrets

oswald

tweet

marine

means

day

futures

cure

lee

will

she

accept

own

them

first

terrorist

service

the vatican

harvey

traitor

they

october

disease

bonfire

now

bolton

born

hoda

still

mike

ritual

order

for

argument

citizenship

islamic

products

enemy

diplomat

states

consulate

administration

dual

expatriate

the united kingdom

monastery

taxation

obama administration

more

popular

this

stop

like

country

right

problem

go home

latest

people

father

tuesday

secretary

just

captive

because

outside

someone

denied

away

learned

burning

worthless

betray

kneel

burned

shedding

wood

onerous

richard

illegal

their

novelty

bureaucratic

consensus

claim

stave

intended

jamal

ery

renounce

reasons

diplomatic

too

upshot

state

through

frustration

almost

tweeting

left

follow

want

agree

later

days

said

others

in the united states

two

pen

dont

pass

kill

again

give up

writing

difficult

the next day

a-few-days

to-go-home

john

sister

strip

stripping

arrival

nationality

off

people at

little

leave

And

Commission

Other

U S

Here

Cant

Both

When

Born To

That

Remove

But

Not

Legal

When She

Bad Idea

Want To Go Home

Give

The

Experts

Disowned

Your

In 2016

Islamic State

Report

Told

Atlantic

Syrian

Put It In

During

Few

The U

Cannot

Holding

Especially

Very

Mike Pompeo

These

Without

While

Protesting

Emerging

Remains

Countries

Was

With

Let

Yemeni

Should

Are

Have

Defect

Appears

Was Here

Had

And That

Begins

Subjective To

Put

Gave

Har

Either

Put It

Eras

Beginning

Successful

Complications

Warren

Groups

Passports

Being

Most

Added

Begin

Far

Graeme

Gulf

Join

Lateralization

Syrians

The United States

Thésée

Random People

Giving

Wanting

Declaration

Bring

Popularity

Beginnings

Wants

Than

Seem

Worse

Avoid

Just Be

Doubting

Letting

Fighters

Avoiding

Given

Along

Stating

Subject

Brings

His

Himself

Terrorists

Americanism

Claiming

Rid

Succession

Traveled

Could

Societies

Forces

A Few

Americanization

Badly

Commonly

Consul

Groupe

Harness

Informal

Marooned

Revoked

Stripped

Unionized

Withholding

John Bolton

Tweets

A Bad

A Single

Any

Begum

Being Difficult

Betrayer

Childrens

Commissioner

Could Be

Days Later

Defective

Deprivation

Emailing

Era Of

Fathered

Given Up

Grims

Have A

In The

Is A

Is That

Its In

Killed

Mostly

Or Both

Ordering

Passed

Randoms

Shamima Begum

Acceptability

Acceptation

Accepter

Acceptive

According To

Americanitis

Among

Any Other

Argumentation

Argumentator

Eing

Erye

Gived

Giveful

Giveness

Givenly

Herse

Isise

Marinee

Miking

Nevered

Saide

Shamima

At Home

Attempted

Avoidant

Badness

Beingness

Borne

Bring On

Canted

Canting

Hoda Muthana

Commissionable

Commissional

Commonality

Commoners

Commonize

Commonness

Defection

Desertion

Difficultness

Diplomatic Service

Doubtedly

Doubtfully

Ebbing

Farness

Fatherly

Firstness

Former

Givenness

Grimming

Grouping

Hers

Ideological

Imprudent

In Writing

Informed

Joining

Laterality

Learnedness

Lees

Legal Right

Legalism

Legality

Monastic

Moste

Nextly

Of Hers

Of His

Of Theirs

Ordered

Otherness

Ownness

Passing

Passingly

Picked

Popularize

Popularized

Randomize

Randomly

Recently

Reportable

Reportedly

Requirements

Ritualism

Rituality

Rituals

Seeming

Seemly

Sistering

Sisterly

Stated

Stately

Staves

Subject To

Subjectable

Subjecting

Subjection

Successive

Successively

Territory

They Are

Throughs

To Let

Traitorous

found ON 2019-03-11 05:42:36 BY esmemes.com

source: reddit